Two key lessons from ‘Scotty Doesn’t Know’

article ip scotty doesnt know WEB
9 November 2018

On the morning of 18 October 2018, the domain scottmorrison.com.au was available for purchase in an expired domain auction for the bargain price of $50.

By that afternoon, Prime Minister the Hon Scott Morrison’s domain had been transferred to a digital strategist, Jack Genesin. Mr Genesin set up a website featuring a solitary smiling picture of the PM accompanied by Lustra’s song ‘Scotty Doesn’t Know’.

Fortunately for the Prime Minister, after much press, Mr Genesin made contact soon afterwards offering to return the domain.

But what should you do if the prankster isn’t so kind hearted?

Two key lessons from ‘Scotty Doesn’t Know’

1.    Where possible, try to avoid the situation

Most domain registrars offer auto-renew functionality. If a domain portfolio is not managed by an external provider, such as a law firm, this is a good option.

2.    Challenge the domain name registration  

It is possible to challenge a domain registration through an administrative process.

While the requirements for this process differ depending on the top level domain (generic or country code), it is generally necessary to show at least that:

  • the challenger owns rights in the name contained in the challenged domain (e.g. trade mark rights);
  • the current holder of the domain does not have a legitimate interest or right to hold the domain; and
  • the current holder of the domain acted in bad faith.

This process is typically fairly swift, with a decision usually handed down within 2-3 months.

The Prime Minister would likely have had strong prospects of recovering the expired domain. Lucky for him (and the person that forgot to renew the domain), a formal challenge was not necessary.


The content of this publication is for reference purposes only. It is current at the date of publication. This content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be obtained before taking any action based on this publication.


Related Content

Key Contact

Jürgen Bebber

Partner. Melbourne
+61 3 9672 3260

Profile